William Smith's Sarah Davidson snapped a 10-10 tie with her fourth goal of the game with 3:24 left.
Fisher, who scored three goals in a 55-second span in the first 2:09 of the contest, led 6-1, before the Herons fought back. William Smith (3-0), who trailed 7-4 at intermission, scored the first five goals of the second half and led 9-7 midway through the second half.
After the two teams traded goals, Fisher's
Allison Christie scored with 6:15 left to make it 10-9 and
Lauren Glavin scored her fourth goal of the game with 3:56 to tie the contest at 10-10.
Fisher's
Laurie Quackenbush scored two goals and record her 45th career assist on Fisher's first goal, making her the program's all-time leader. Quackenbush already ranks as Fisher's all-time leader in points.
Vicki Sahm stopped seven shots in goal for the Cardinals.
Fisher will return to action on Saturday and will play its first Empire 8 Conference game at Alfred University.