Matthew Herbert returned to Fisher as an assistant coach in November 2021 following a successful career at both Fisher and Geneseo. Matthew was a Livingston County All-Star in the high school ranks in both cross country and track and field. While at Geneseo, he finished sixth at the Daniel Walker Invitational with a time of 26:34 and would go on to take 16th place at the Highlander Invite in Houghton with a time of 27:26.15.